Definitely give Schooners another try, Xi Bowhunter. Out of all the times we've eaten there, we did have one bad experience but we chalked that up to Schooners just having an "off night". People have off nights, so I think businesses do, too. The last time we ate there, they were offering winter lunch specials & we got grouper tacos with beans & rice and a salad for $5.99, I think. It was awesome!
As always, their web cams let me visit whenever I need a quick beach fix!