I really like the area where the Provincial is better, but it's really just a personal choice. The MDP seems kind of far away from everything, to me anyway. It's beautiful and a nice place, but I like the Provincial better. Great area; quieter part of quarter toward Esplanade but not too far from the fun. Stella! and Irene's are both great restaurants right there. Chartres is a wonderful street as is Royal for shopping, people-watching, great food, etc. but not in the midst of Bourbon.
When are you going?
Lucy